Queer West - Serving West Toronto, Ontario



August to October 2009 - News Archive

Queer West Community Network

OUTeXpressions enewspaper

OUTEXPRESSIONS newspaper is a not for profit publication of Gay West Community Network Inc. (Masthead) Copyright 2016. All Rights Reserved. We have been bringing news & event listings to readers since 1995. OUTexpressions, is one of Gay Toronto's leading media publications, with the hottest happenings in the coolest places. We are not an exclusive gay publication. Queerwest.org family of websites receives 40,000 hits a day, from within Canada and abroad. Queer West is consistently ranked #1 (Page One) in Bing and Google, for most search returns. Outexpressions on Twitter Thank you for your interest in QueerWest.org For Event Submissions, Email: outexpressions@gmail.com 416-879-7954

THE QUEER WEST TORONTO SCENE About Our Festivals | Board of Directors | Contact Us | Accommodations | Bar & Restaurant Guide | Businesses | Events Theatre | Events Today? | Events Weekly & Monthly | Our History | Queer West Festivals | West Village Travel Guide | West Village Street Map

The Stonewall riot based on false history

Monday August 3, 2009 (Robin Evans, New York, New York) - Forty years ago on June 27 a young reporter for the Village Voice penned a snarky article declaring that a riot outside the Stonewall Inn in Sheridan Square represented an outbreak of what the headline to his story called “Gay Power”. That same reporter, Lucien V. Truscott IV, now writes in a New York Times op-ed that the myth of Stonewall is based on a false history. But Truscott’s his own published report from four decades ago tells a slightly different history.

A myth develops from a history, but they’re distinct. Myth adds layers to history, turning it into something other than the simple record of an event or person.

What we commemorate in June is the myth of Stonewall. We commemorate the great notion that somehow in a time long ago and at a place most of us have never been something happened that affects us and moves us even now.

“A prominent Stonewall myth holds that the riots were an uprising by the gay community against decades of oppression.” Truscott says it his current reflection on those hot nights four decades ago in Greenwich Village.

That’s the myth we celebrate each June.

He says now that the myth would be historical and “true” only “if the ‘gay community’ consisted of Stonewall patrons.” But that’s not who rioted, he says: “The bar’s regulars, though, were mostly teenagers from Queens, Long Island, and New Jersey, with a few young drag queens and homeless youths who squatted in abandoned tenements on the Lower East Side.”

Based on a good deal of contrary historical evidence, one could set Truscott’s recollection aside except for one thing: The man who is recalling that history is the same guy who wrote the most comprehensive contemporary press account of the riots. Truscott’s article, published by the Village Voice in its July 3, 1969 issue, was given the headline “Gay Power Comes to Sheridan Square”. The issue hit the streets while the uprisings continued each night outside the bar (and just down the street from the Voice offices at the time).

Truscott’s current recollections are included in a New York Times op-ed, “The Real Mob at Stonewall”. Queery summarized it with the headline, “The Stonewall Riot Was Not, In Fact, the Gay Community's Uprising”.

The great LGBT history website OutHistory.org features a collection of primary documents about an event whose name is among the best known among LGBT folks: Stonewall. The name is known, but anything more than the vague outlines of the actual events that happened 40 years ago at the bar named “Stonewall” have become mythic, often mentioned in loudly amplified but little listened-to speeches at rallies this time of year. In each speech, the events of those nights in June are colored with a slightly different hue. In each speech, the events of that night are used – as myths usually are – to amplify whatever lesson the speaker is trying to teach.

But OutHistory offers a raw look at those hot nights 40 years ago, including a fascinating letter that author and essayist Edmund White sent to two friends on July 8, 1969. White is the author of A Boy's Own Story (1982) and The Farewell Symphony (1997) along with numerous essays and short stories. His letter was written to two friends, and demonstrates the same kind of elegant precision of language that characterizes his essays.

© Copyright 2017 Gay West Community Network Inc.
Mailing Address: 562 Dufferin St. Suite B1, Toronto ON M6K 2A9